Could be but do you seriously think this 40+ year old man with kids and a family..who many times has said that he left Liberty alone quite a bit, and she was practically a single mother…didn’t know what he was doing? Like we claim Kristen knew what she was doing because she’s old enough. Same difference. We don’t know what actually happened. We never will. What we do know is the people who are married in the scandal don’t seem to be suffering..whereas the two who aren’t married are suffering. We know Liberty has lied, at her runway show over the w/e she said she hadn’t stepped out of the house in 7 weeks, but there is proof she did many times. We do know that Rupert is a scumbag who is walking around as if the world is all okay. We do know Kristen has been blamed 100% for this cheating scandal. We do know Kristen’s parents are divorcing and we do know Kristen’s dad is battling cancer. More than that we do know that the very two people who have brought Twilight to life and given us so much joy over the past 4 years are suffering…and we do know that this fandom is all sorts of screwed up.

I thought she was losing weight for a new role in something. Wasn’t that why she was spotted in the gym a couple times? She looks good though.

Hollywood is full of those kinds of people, since the beginnging of movie making.

Just because you did doesn’t mean it always works that way for everyone. Circumstances are different. Everyone is different It has happened more than once with me. And I stopped all but 2. Sometimes you are in a situation that isn’t a friend and you can get killed if you handle it wrong. I am glad you were able to stop it. Maybe there were reasons you could do so. IDK. But don’t hold yourself up as a moral model of “what’s right” as I think you are doing.That would automatically make Kristen wrong and you just don’t know what her situation was that afternoon. And then to have people extrapolate and accuse her of more than that on absolutely nothing but cheap tabloid gossip (it doesn’t always have to be in the zines you know) is reprehensible.

I hadn’t heard Kristens dad has cancer, all I know is that Rob and Kristen are obviously suffering, anyone one can see that and the situation is just sad. I’m sure if Kristen could turn back time and took the time to think of everything she would lose, she wouldn’t have answered that call. I don’t know RS wife I do feel bad for her and he certainly doesn’t seem to be suffering at all or suffering the backlash that he should, that I don’t get. But it Rob and Kristen that are the main concern in all this for me and I hate seeing them and the fans like this.

She looks sick.

I did not know that Kristen’s dad had cancer either. And yes, Rob and Kristen are suffering — it’s physical and you can see it. When both were promoting their films it was noticed. It’s true — we don’t know what happened. But I do know this — nothing is black and white. I’m not saying that Kristen is not accountable for her actions — she is. And she took responsibility for that. But nothing is black and white and I posted that because it is something to consider.

I know fans of each of them, say oh their fine and have move on and they very well have, thats for them to decide. But I agree they do not look like their happy and carefree old selves like they were. It s true nothing is black and white, I’m glad you posted it, its not the first person to suggest a similar possible theory

I heard someone say that both RS and Kristen with their positions it’s easy to get caught up in that since of entitlement and people can end up letting it go to their heads and end up crossing the line and they did cross the line and with that, it ended up hurting everyone involved. I still it doesn’t absolve anyone of responsibilty for their on behavior or choices, just another take on human behavior.

I never stated I held myself as a moral role model, just I found myself in a simulair situation that you were speaking of. Those are the word you applied to it, not mine. As far as the situation with Kristen, I’ve had the opinion that RS was 90% to blame for the whole mess, I was once 22 and know what its like to be that age and to be young and dumb. I just wasn’t gulity of that particulair mistake, we all make stupid choices in life, she just had the misfortune to photograhed when she made it, most us aren’t.

I don’t know anything about the THG’s never read them, so if your implying was it just unwanted kissing, no I was also pinned down and had to call out for help. But you seem to all ready have your on spin on it.

Thank you! I’m in total agreement with you. And yes the more I think about this scandal the more confused I get.

A guy who was a best friend with you pinned you down! did you not know about this violence in him before this, in many other ways. I was living with someone on a homestead: no running water, no electricity, very calm and peaceful life. One day one of the ducks got into the garden and tore up a mess of greens – or something. Just doing what ducks do when ducks get into your vegetable garden. Just being a duck, that’s all. He grabbed it by the neck, swung it around and bashed its head open on the fence. Up to then I saw nothing like that with him. A considerate and wonderful lover.

Well I watched that and thought, time to get out soon my girl. And I did.

Actually he was wonderful to me. But when I saw that I knew he was a loose cannon. One has to be cautious with that type. I loved him but not so passionately that I wanted to risk it.

i love u